Prophet Pulls Grading Supplies

What You Need to Submit Cards for Grading

PSA and TAG want the same basic setup for standard-size cards: a clear penny sleeve inside a 3 5/16" × 4 7/8" semi-rigid holder, not a hard toploader. For Beckett, follow the packaging instructions on Beckett’s grading page or in your confirmation.

The packing kit

Pack in this order: card, clear penny sleeve, semi-rigid holder, between two Ding Defenders, then a new box.
  • Clear penny sleeves (PSA says to avoid solid or opaque sleeves)
  • Semi-rigid holders / Card Savers, 3 5/16" × 4 7/8" — no tape, pull tabs, sticky notes, or writing on the holder
  • Two Ding Defenders card shipping protectors, one on each side of the stack
  • Two or three rubber bands, snug but not crushing (TAG also allows painter’s tape)
  • Bubble wrap or similar cushioning, plus filler so the stack cannot slide
  • A new, sturdy cardboard box (the 6x4x2 boxes we use) and packing tape (not painter’s tape, Scotch tape, or reused tape on the outside)
  • Printed paperwork, with cards stacked in form order, Item #1 on top
  • A trackable, insured inbound shipment — PSA and TAG do not insure the trip in unless you buy a specific add-on or kit

Don’t send: toploaders, magnetic one-touches, screw-downs, team bags around individual cards (TAG), taped-shut holders, labels on the holders, or a flimsy envelope as the only packaging. TAG prefers a box.

What we use at Prophet Pulls

These are the supplies we buy on Amazon for our own cards. Toploaders are for storage and everyday shipping, not for grading submissions.

More details

TAG says toploaders, one-touches, and screw-downs can cause delays and handling fees. TAG may reject worn or damaged-looking packages. Beckett’s terms say it is not liable for loss or damage it can reasonably show happened while the package was not in its custody, so arrange inbound insurance with your carrier.

Also useful: a centering tool or card-centered app and a bright, even light so you can judge the card before you spend the grading fee; a PSA Submission Kit, sold through PSA; a TAG Submission Kit, sold on TAG’s site for continental U.S. orders; and a short video of each card and of you sealing the box (TAG specifically recommends this). Painter’s tape is only for bundling the Ding Defenders on a TAG shipment, not for sealing Card Savers.

Re-read the packing section in the PSA, TAG, or Beckett guide for addresses and insurance details before you ship.

Some links on this page are affiliate links; Prophet Pulls may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

As an Amazon Associate, Prophet Pulls earns from qualifying purchases.

Please note: Grade outcomes are not guaranteed. Prophet Pulls LLC does not accept, ship, or handle customer cards. Use this list to pack a submission you are sending yourself to PSA, TAG, or Beckett.